Thursday, February 28, 2019

"One-Punch Man Vol. 8," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 8, written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This particular volume of One-Punch Man introduces S-Class hero King in more detail, and includes bonus chapters that focus on S-Class Hero Bang trying to recruit Saitama to his dojo and Saitama finding a missing cat for the daughter of the director of the Hero Association.

Pros:
  • A few ongoing pros: the draftsmanship, Saitama (who's characterization has been more consistent over the last few volumes, i.e. with him showing less interest in public opinion), and all of the interesting characters (King included).
  •  Genos' relationship with Saitama is precious, especially when he (minor spoiler) buys all of the cellphone hangers based on Saitama.
Cons:
  • A few on-going cons: the lack of women in the narrative (S-Class hero Tornado disappeared from this volume), Puri-Puri Prisoner (the whole character, though he did not appear in this volume either), the mismatch between the right-to-left orientation of the visuals and the left-to-right orientation of the "sound effects," and details being lost in the binding process.
  • (nit-pick) There are so many interesting characters that show up in the story that it is a shame that they don't appear more often.  Then again, the manga is called, "One-Punch Man," not, "interesting side character manga."
Conclusion:
I am happy to report that this volume was still a pleasure to read, even after all the material from the anime has been covered.  It was also much more character-focused than the last few volumes (which, due to the Dark Matter invasion, were much more battle focused).  I'm still invested in the characters and excited to see where the story goes next.

Final Score:
8.5/10

Wednesday, February 27, 2019

"One-Punch Man Vol. 7," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 7, written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This particular volume of One-Punch Man wraps up the Dark Matter invasion and discusses the aftermath.  It also includes a few more bonus chapters than were included in the last few volumes.

Pros:
  • A few ongoing pros: the draftsmanship, Saitama (who's characterization has been more consistent over the last few volumes, i.e. with him showing less interest in public opinion), and the "bonus content," that did not make it into the anime (since what's being covered is included in the first season of the One-Punch Man anime).
  • I know I highlighted the draftsmanship above, but this volume also has more than a few 2-page spreads that are jaw dropping.
  • One of the bonus chapters focused on something quite interesting: the relationship between the police and the Hero Association.  The tension between the two organizations was fascinating, especially since they ostensibly share the same goal.
Cons:
  • A few on-going cons: the lack of women in the narrative (though S-Class hero Tornado has played a larger role in this volume), Puri-Puri Prisoner (the whole character), the mismatch between the right-to-left orientation of the visuals and the left-to-right orientation of the "sound effects," and details being lost in the binding process.
  • It's probably because I was so spoiled by the anime, but the the fight between Boros and Saitama just doesn't live up to the animated version.  Then again, this could be a secret pro, since it's an excuse to re-watch that absolutely bonkers fight (and its also not a fair comparison, since the animated version has motion, music, color, etc).
Conclusion:
I am still having a lot of fun with this manga, and am most excited to see where it goes now that the manga has covered all of the material from the anime (which I happened to see first). These next few chapters are going to be do-or-die: it's time to see if the story can maintain its momentum.

Final Score:
8.5/10

"One-Punch Man Vol. 6," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 6, written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This particular volume of One-Punch Man introduces "Dark Matter," and their invasion of Earth.  The group is lead by Boros, the self-proclaimed "Dominator of the Universe," who came to earth based on a prophecy that there would be someone strong there to fight.

Pros:
  • A few ongoing pros: the draftsmanship, Saitama (even if his characterization is a little inconsistent, what with him vacillating between wanting fans and not caring about public opinion), and the "bonus content," that did not make it into the anime (since what's being covered is still well within the first season of the One-Punch Man anime).
  • ONE's irreverent writing style produces a lot of laughs.  This includes the powerful seer who dies when she, "choked on a cough drop."
  • I know I highlighted the draftsmanship above, but this volume has more than a few 2-page spreads that are jaw dropping.
Cons:
  • A few on-going cons: the lack of women in the narrative (though S-Class hero Tornado has played a larger role in this volume), Puri-Puri Prisoner (the whole character), the mismatch between the right-to-left orientation of the visuals and the left-to-right orientation of the "sound effects," and details being lost in the binding process.
  • It's probably because I was so spoiled by the anime, but the "first phase," of the fight between Boros and Saitama isn't really depicted in the manga.  Then again, this could be a secret pro, since it's an excuse to re-watch that absolutely bonkers fight.
Conclusion:
I am still having a lot of fun with this manga, and am most excited to see where it goes once it finishes sharing content with the anime.  My guess is that the manga will overtake the anime in volume 8, so we'll see if the story can maintain its momentum.

Final Score:
8/10

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

"Killer By Nature," by Jan Smith

Killer by Nature follows Dr. Diane Buckley as she seeks to determine whether a string of murders were committed by a notorious but imprisoned serial killer, or a copy-cat. The story plays out over ten 30 minute chapters.  The story only gets more complicated as it progresses as the bodies start piling up and the killer manages to escape police custody.

I received this book as a free, "Audible Original" for the month of February, 2019.

Pros:
  • The story features a full ensemble cast
  • The story plays out in 30 minute "episodes," making each reasonably digestible
Cons:
  • The story lacks a narrator, so every action must be portrayed either through dialogue or through sound effects.  This can make it difficult to tell what's actually happening in a given scene
  • The amount of tension that relies on the characters either not answering their phone / listening to messages in a timely manner is too high
  • I was never really invested in the characters; I got through to the end out of a desire for completion and to see if my theory was correct, not due to emotional attachment to the characters.
  • The "big reveal" at the very end of the story* doesn't really add to the narrative, other than make the killer a hair more tragic in retrospect.
  • (nit-pick) The repeated use of the book's title and "stinger" at the start of each episode gets annoying
Conclusion:
The book was fine for being free, but there were far too many issues to recommend it at any price (let alone full price).  Perhaps I could have overlooked a lot of these issues if the book didn't commit a fatal flaw for mystery books: as a reader, I felt like I couldn't have guessed who the killer was based on the information provided.  Ultimately, the book isn't so bad its good, or even so bad its interesting; it is just mediocre.

---

* SPOILERS AHEAD:
The "big reveal" is that Dr. Buckley's father is being held in the same prison as the murderer, making the murderer's statement that, "the distance between her reality and his is too great," a bit ironic.

Monday, February 25, 2019

"One-Punch Man Vol. 5," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 5, written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This volume focuses primarily on the Deep Sea King, and his campaign of aggression against the heroes (and villains?) who stand against him.  The volume also includes a bit of bonus material where Saitama encounters bank robbers and hi-jinx ensue.

Pros:
  • A few ongoing pros: the draftsmanship, Saitama (even if his characterization is a little inconsistent, what with him vacillating between wanting fans and not caring about public opinion), and the "bonus content," that did not make it into the anime (since what's being covered is still well within the first season of the One-Punch Man anime).
  • It could be hold-over hype and good will from the anime, but the climatic scene with Mumen Rider is still clutch as hell.
  • The interactions between Genos and Saitama are endearing, even 5 volumes into the manga.
Cons:
  • A few on-going cons: the lack of women in the narrative, Puri-Puri Prisoner (the whole character), the mismatch between the right-to-left orientation of the visuals and the left-to-right orientation of the "sound effects," and details being lost in the binding process.
  • As I mentioned above, I think Saitama's characterization seems a touch inconsistent.  On one hand he is excited about having fans and receiving fan mail, but he is also willing to be a "heel," for the good of other heroes*.
Conclusion:
I am still having a lot of fun with this manga, and am most excited to see where it goes once it finishes sharing content with the anime.  My guess is that the manga will overtake the anime in the next few volumes, so we'll see if the story can maintain its momentum.

---

Spoiler:
* by claiming that the other heroes had a large hand in weakening the Sea King, when really, Saitama was the one that defeated it.

Sunday, February 24, 2019

"One-Punch Man Vol. 4," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 4, written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This volume focuses on a meteor that threatens to level an entire city, the introduction of the Clan of Seafolk (who want to rise from the sea and destroy humanity, obviously), and the introduction of "Puri-Puri Prisoner," a character I will discuss in more detail below.

Pros:
  • Surprising no one, Saitama continues to be a stand-out character.  His response to the fallout of the meteor incident is great. 
  • The draftsmanship continues to be top-notch, even if one of the characters is getting serious side-eye from me (see below).
  • Even if the manga does not have the same level of kinetic energy as an animated show, I love all of the bonus content you get with this format.  This includes everything from little interactions to whole chapters that never made it into the anime.  One such example in this volume is S-Class hero Bang's skepticism towards the hero association (e.g. that they are more interested in maintaining their position of financial stability and societal importance than they are in making any single rescue).
Cons:
  • Puri-Puri Prisoner (henceforth referred to as P3).  Ugh.  For context, P3 is an S-Class ranked hero who, in his own words, is, "doing 10,000 years for getting grabby with men."  He also threatened to  "deep kiss," all the other inmates at the maximum security prison he is being held at, "as punishment."  The grossness of this is only magnified by the fact that all of the other inmates live in fear of him and his advances.  If this was meant to be played for laughs, it falls on its face.  Even if P3's actions are recognized as wrong in the universe of the manga, the lack of other LGBT characters in the series means that P3 comes off mostly as a gross stereotype.  Maybe his character will be developed as the story continues, but I'm not optimistic.
  • The women featured in the last volume have disappeared.  This is a shame, especially considering ONE's ability to craft interesting, off-the-wall characters.
  • (nit-pick) The mismatch between sound effects and reading direction continues in this volume, though it seemed slightly less prevalent than it was in volume 2.  To be clear, I am listing this as a nit-pick because I don't know that there is a reasonable solution that could address this issue.  As I stated in reviews of previous volumes, details being lost in the book's binding is also still an issue.
Conclusion:
My excitement to continue reading this series is tempered somewhat by the introduction of Puri-Puri Prisoner.  With that being said, I think the serious has more than enough good things to outweigh the bad, and my hope is that P3 will have an ever decreasing role as the manga progresses.

Final Score:
8/10

"One-Punch Man Vol. 3," by ONE

One-Punch Man, Vol. 3 written by ONE and illustrated by Yusuke Murata, stars Saitama, the titular, "One-Punch Man."  After years of training, Saitama has become so powerful he can defeat virtually every enemy with a single strike.  There's just one problem: according to Saitama himself, "overwhelming strength ... is boring."

This particular volume focuses on Saitama and Genos joining the Hero Association, another encounter with Speed O' Sound Sonic, and the first introduction of heroines in the story ("Miss Blizzard," and "Terrible Tornado").

Pros:
  • As expected, Saitama is still a badass.  He also has another great quote during the bonus chapter of Vol. 3: "Who decides limits?  And based on what?  ... Could the you of tomorrow beat you today?  Instead of giving in, move forward."
  • Again, there is more great character work and draftsmanship.
  • Even if the manga does not have the same level of kinetic energy as an animated show, I love all of the bonus content you get with this format.  This includes everything from little interactions to whole chapters that never made it into the anime.
Cons:
  • It's mildly annoying that it took 3 volumes for a heroine of any form or fashion to appear in the manga.  The two that appear are also gone pretty quickly (though I happen to know they make more of an appearance later on in the series).
  • (nit-pick) The mismatch between sound effects and reading direction continues in this volume, though it seemed slightly less prevalent than it was in volume 2.  To be clear, I am listing this as a nit-pick because I don't know that there is a reasonable solution that could address this issue.  As I stated in reviews of previous volumes, details being lost in the book's binding is also still an issue.
Conclusion:
Three volumes in and I am still on the hype train.  I still think fans of the anime should check out the manga, and I love all the extra little insights I am getting from this format (a la world building and minor characters that don't appear in the anime).

Final Score:
8.5/10

Over the Garden Wall #2, by Pat McHale and Jim Campbell

3.5 / 5 From the Publisher The Tale of Fred the Horse! This issue takes place between episodes 4-5 of the Cartoon Network miniseries and tel...