Saturday, June 6, 2020

Wonderland222 Undated A5 Planner

I purchased the Wonderland222 Undated Planner just over 3 months ago in late February, 2020.  I bought it to use as my "daily driver," for journaling and writing (not as a planner).  I recently completed the journal (i.e. filled it from cover to cover), and I have some thoughts about the product.  

Basic Info:
  • Price: $27 USD
  • Paper Type: Tomoe River, 52 GSM
  • Format: Grid
  • Pages: 365, numbered
  • Link
Pros:
  • The notebook has plenty of pages for long writing sessions
  • The notebook is fairly priced, especially considering its feature-set when compared to other notebooks in the "premium stationery" segment
  • The notebook uses numbered Tomoe River paper.  I rarely see this combination, even in other premium Tomoe River notebooks
  • The ribbons have held up well over the course of the notebook's use, neither fraying nor discoloring.
  • I've found grid formatting to be a nice in-between for the structure of lined paper and the freedom of blank paper.  In other words, the structure is there if you want it, but you don't have to use it.
  • I like that there is a place to date every page.
  • I appreciate the inclusion of an index, even if I didn't use it much.
  • The notebook has no problem laying flat, even on end pages (e.g. pages 2 and 364).
Cons:
  • Though the notebook has a lot of great features, I didn't use them as much as I expected to (e.g. the index, page numbers, etc)
  • Try as I might, I still prefer lined paper.  Since I used the notebook for writing and journaling instead of planning, the grid was more of a hindrance than a benefit for me
  • The notebook (as of the time of writing) is only available in one size and color.  To be fair, though, the first issue can easily be remedied with a cover.
  • The top of the page has a large "forehead" because of the area carved out for the date.  I often left this part of the page blank, or only used a line for a title.  As a result, I left a fair amount of blank space in the notebook (see picture below).

Conclusion:
The "Wonderland222 Undated A5 Planner" represents a great value for stationery obsessives.  The combination of price, feature set, and availability means it is definitely worth considering for your next planner / bujo.  For my part, I struggled to find issues with this product except on matters of personal taste.  The fact that Wonderland222 is also releasing a B6 notebook with even more color options is just icing on the cake.  Definitely check this one out.

Final Score:
8.5/10

Saturday, April 18, 2020

Our Dreams At Dusk (Vol. 1) by Yuhki Kamatani, Jocelyne Allen (Translator)

Pros:

  • The art style has an interesting, surreal quality to it, and deftly transitions between the grounded and the "out there."
  • The story features LGBT characters of a few stripes, and said characters both struggle and have agency (i.e. the work isn't just "exploitation porn").  The story is grounded in the experience of a realistic character, so the work never feels preachy or heavy-handed.
  • I enjoyed the work enough to finish it, and I'm curious enough about the characters to try the next volume.

Cons:

  • The visual metaphors are fine, but a bit obvious / tired (e.g. a character "tearing down a wall" literally as they figuratively come to terms with some aspect of their character)
  • (nit-pick) Maybe it made more sense in the author's native language, but "Someone-san" is such a weird name it distracted me from the narrative
  • Speaking of Someone-san, they are, at times, a more interesting character than the POV character(s).  They border on being a magical force of change.

Conclusion:
Nothing about the work blew me away.  The art came the closest, but I never had a "wow!" moment.  Still, I enjoyed the story and appreciate that LGBT characters are both represented and able to struggle without the story feeling exploitative.  Ultimately, while it won't many my list of "all time favorites," I think it has lots of potential to help people who are struggling with their own sexuality and/or who want to know more about what it's like to be a member of the LGBT community.

Final Score:
7/10

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

"North," by Scott Jurek (featuring Jenny Jurek)

From The Publisher
From the author of the bestseller Eat and Run, a thrilling memoir about his grueling, exhilarating, and immensely inspiring 46-day run to break the speed record for the Appalachian Trail.

Pros

  • It's interesting to peer into Jurek's thought process for running the Appalachian Trail (AT), from planning to what the day-to-day looked and felt like
  • I appreciate that Jurek's wife, Jenny (an accomplished runner in her own right), is given time to share her thoughts and memories from the experience.  She provides about 1/3 of the book / narration.
  • The story includes a veritable who's-who of the ultra-running community.  
  • I was excited to see how the story would end (e.g. would Jurek capture the record?).  I found it easy to feel "pumped up," by the last few chapters of the book.

Cons

  • The writing can be a bit repetitive at times (i.e. talking about pain, the mental game of completing the race).  This borders on a nit-pick, though, because I'm guessing that's what the author was actually experiencing. 
  • I wouldn't have minded if the author leaned into the Travel Log aspect of the story, given that he was running through so many states.  Again, I can't really fault the author, though, because that's not what the book claims to be.
  • It's a shame Jenny isn't highlighted on hardcover version of the work, given that she contributes about 1/3 of "North."  She does appear on the Audible cover, however.

Conclusion
I think Jurek's tribe (i.e. runners, hikers, etc), will appreciate this work.  Fans of sports-focused non-fiction will also likely enjoy this work.  It may not change your life, but it may just serve as inspiration for your next project, outing, or goal.

Final Score
8/10

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Clairefontaine Neo Deco A5 Notebook (Diamond, Lined)

From The Manufacturer: 
This Neo Deco themed A5-sized notebook features 48 sheets (96 pages) of super smooth ivory 90g Clairefontaine lined paper with a sewn spine binding. The cover is made of cardboard with a matte coating, finished with shiny gold printed accents.  Photo courtesy of Goulet Pens.



Basic Info:
Price: $8.50 USD
Size: A5 (8.3 inches by 5.9 inches)
Format: Lined
Purchased From: Goulet Pens

Pros:
  • The notebook is available with a number of aesthetically pleasing covers.  
    • This is what initially drew me to the notebook. 
  • The notebook held up well over my time filling it (approximately a month), though I did almost always have it in a cover of some sort.
  • There is almost no bleed or show-through when using my collection of fountain pens.
Cons:
  • Some inks take minutes to dry; I had this problem even with medium nibs and a fairly bog-standard ink (Pilot Black).   
    • if you are going to use this notebook with fountain pens, I recommend having blotter paper (or even tissue) handy.
  • The paper feels different than other Clairefontaine notebooks I've owned (such as the 1951 cloth-bound notebook).  I'm not sure if this particular example is a lemon, but both products are listed as having "90g Clairefontaine paper."
    • I would describe the paper as "glossy bordering on laminated," instead of just, "glossy smooth."  
  • The paper squeaks when written on more often than I would like.  
  • (nit-pick) The notebook is stitch-bound along its spine.  I am listing this as a nitpick because 1) I don't find this binding method as aesthetically pleasing (but it may work for you), and 2) I am concerned said binding type may not hold up over the long run.  In particular, I've seen bindings like this fray over time, even if this example did not.
  • (nit-pick) The notebook is barebones, eschewing features often found in other notebooks (e.g. a ribbon, back pocket, perforated paper, or other pack-ins).  
    • This wasn't a deal-breaker for me because most Tomoe River notebooks don't include these features either, but if they are essential to you, you may want to look elsewhere.
  • (nit-pick) The paper exhibits a bit of feathering.
Conclusion:
If you're not a fountain pen obsessive and you appreciate the aesthetics, this may be a good notebook for you.  As far as I'm concerned, the notebook is fine for what it is.  It doesn't "tick enough boxes," to take me away from my current favorite paper type (Tomoe River), however.  

Final Score: 
6/10

Over the Garden Wall #2, by Pat McHale and Jim Campbell

3.5 / 5 From the Publisher The Tale of Fred the Horse! This issue takes place between episodes 4-5 of the Cartoon Network miniseries and tel...